I-town-90 wrote:
I didn't try to "portend" we scheduled those teams year in and year out. You obviously missed the point. I happened to have named a few small schools who are powerhouses and can kick the crap out of nearly every D2 school in the state. I am trying to point out that your argument that the "talent pool" is the same doesn't hold water and is ridiculous.
You have made you opinion known, and so have I. We can let the readers decided which schedule is tougher, playing teams like Coldwater, Ursaline, and Mooney, or playing D2 schools that have won a combined 6 games in 4 years.
first of all, let me dispell some of the "untruths" that you have thrown out there that i supposedly said or a false stance that i have taken....
i never once said that scheduling Mooney, Coldwater, etc. was scheduling "down". YOU created that in your own mind.
i never once said whose schedule was or was not "tougher". another filament of YOUR illumination.
my whole point and my ONLY point all along has been that scheduling teams like D4 Hartley (same as ironton) isn't "scheduling UP". (note that i didn't say it was scheduling "down").
and as far as talent pools go, your schools numbers of boys is close enough to Hartley's that it satisfies OHSAA requirements to put them in the same division so the same relative amount of boys are available at each school to play sports. maybe you have a bunch of boys walking around the halls that have decided not to jump in the "pool" but the odds of having the opportunity of equal talent should certainly be there.